AI’s role in healthcare is increasing every day. Still, with greater integration, there is also a growing need to balance innovation with HIPAA regulations. AI in healthcare is growing with new possibilities for expansion, shaping the advancement. However, while opportunities arise, risks are also heightened, particularly about protected health information. Healthcare providers and associates in the US have no choice but to comply with the law known as HIPAA. The regulations help support trust, maintain data security, and prevent any potential data abuse; thus, proper use of AI must be done to be consistent with HIPAA.
HIPAA’s Importance Rises Amidst AI Advancement
AI relies fundamentally on data. For training models, this information is generally in the form of massive datasets consisting of the patients’ medical histories, treatment and diagnosis information, and even billing and claims data, and other types of sensitive data that are covered under PHI.
Given this reliance on data, protecting and safeguarding PHI is vital. HIPAA sets the specific requirements with respect to how PHI can be created, transmitted, stored, and shared. Given this framework, when AI tools are deployed in the healthcare organization without careful consideration of HIPAA, the following instances can take place:
- Unauthorized breaches of PHI.
- Risks of re-identification of data, even in datasets that have been de-identified.
- Improper relationships with AI vendors who do not comply with HIPAA’s requirements to ensure PHI is protected.
Areas of HIPAA and AI Overlaps
HIPAA and AI also intersect in certain areas, such as:
- Data privacy and de-identification
HIPAA allows for the de-identification of PHI by two methods:
- Safe Harbor: Removing 18 particular identifiers such as name, address, social security number, etc.
- Expert Determination: An expert certifying that the probability of re-identifying an individual is very small.
For AI, de-identification acts as a safeguard for PHI, not a protection against re-identification. Advanced algorithms in healthcare technology security are sometimes capable of reverse engineering identifications, which leads AI teams to recognize that HIPAA’s de-identification techniques may need to be reinforced with additional safeguards.
- Vendor and Business Associate Contracts (BAA)
Many healthcare entities are not building AI tools internally. Instead, they are relying on their vendors. Under the HIPAA regulation, any vendor that touches PHI becomes a Business Associate and is required to have a BAA with your organization.
A sound Business Associate Agreement should:
- Limit the use of the data solely to the purposes that the parties have agreed to
- Provide for security safeguards equivalent to HIPAA
- The agreement should provide for breach notification and liability for penalties
- The agreement would allow a client audit or documentation to ensure compliance.
- Biases, Fairness, and Patient Rights
While the HIPAA regulations’ primary focus is privacy and security, AI raises a secondary compliance risk. The risk is that the algorithms are biased and create discriminatory outcomes, exposing the entity to enforcement action from the OCR.
Healthcare entities need to make sure that they are:
- Testing the AI models for fairness across all demographics
- Documenting the steps you have taken to eliminate error,
- Ensuring that the patients retain their rights under the Privacy Rule, and encouraging access to records with the use of AI.
Security Safeguards and Risk Assessments
The HIPAA Security Rules state that covered healthcare entities must conduct periodic risk analyses and implement three kinds of safeguards. These AI HIPAA compliance guidelines include administrative, physical, and technical safeguards. For AI, this means that:
- Encryption is vital, whether in transit or at rest, when using PHI for model training or inference.
- Access controls are implemented that restrict sensitive data to only authorized staff or systems.
- Audit trails are maintained that track who accessed what data and when.
- Regular penetration testing is performed, which shows your AI systems can’t be exploited in an attempt to gain access to sensitive data.
As the threat of cybersecurity increases, the HHS has proposed updates to the HIPAA Security Rule, raising expectations for technical safeguards. Organizations implementing AI should assume that regulators will request safeguards that are considered cutting-edge.
Strategies for Maintaining HIPAA AI Compliance
For healthcare providers and associated businesses that are subject to HIPAA guidelines and regulations, HIPAA AI compliance strategies can impact the effectiveness of these integrations. Some effective methods include the following:
Embed HIPAA into the AI pipeline.
Making compliance a priority rather than an afterthought is paramount. Every AI project should assess HIPAA compliance obligations at the forefront of every phase of the project: data acquisition, training, deployment, and monitoring.
Use privacy-preserving AI
Examples include approaches like federated learning, whereby models learn from distributed datasets without the centralization of the PHI. Combined with differential privacy, this protects individuals by adding noise to their data.
Be more stringent around contracts and the process for vendor due diligence.
Before onboarding any AI vendor, ensure that the vendor requires proof of compliance through SOC 2 reports, penetration tests, and certification of training staff on HIPAA. Also, ensure that BHAs are not boilerplate but cater to the context of AI.
Continuously update risk assessments.
Risk assessments should be conducted for the life of the project according to HIPAA standards instead of once. Each time you upgrade, retrain, or add a new instance of an AI system, complete the risk assessment again.
Staff training
Providing essential information about HIPAA regulations to clinicians, data scientists, and IT staff. The risk assessment should be finished every time a new instance of the AI system is added to the system, retrained, or deployed.
Conclusion
AI will undeniably shape the future of healthcare. By incorporating privacy, security, and fairness into every AI project, every organization will not only avoid penalties but also create systems that patients can trust and providers can confidently use. As AI continues to take on a bigger role in healthcare and design a brighter future, its constant alignment with HIPAA rules, and potentially, the advancement of HIPAA rules to stay ahead of AI’s evolution, will keep patient rights safe.
Related Posts
